The whole of the sixth chapter in Hebrew and English, six places the edition keeps two readings open, and six questions for a group.
שלשה אבות ותולדותיהן ושבעה כוכבים [נ"א כובשין] וצבאותיהן ושנים עשר גבולי אלכסונין וראיה לדבר עדים נאמנין עולם שנה נפש חק שנים עשר [נ"א עשרה] ושבעה ושלשה ופקידן בתלי וגלגל ולב. שלשה אש ומים ורוח אש למעלה ומים למטה ורוח חק מכריע בינתים וסימן לדבר האש נושא את המים. מ"ם דוממת שי"ן שורקת אל"ף חוק מכריע בינתים:
Three fathers and their offspring; and seven stars [another version: conquerors] and their hosts; and twelve diagonal boundaries. And proof of the matter: faithful witnesses: world, year, soul. A statute of twelve [another version: ten], and seven, and three; and He appointed them in the Teli, and the Galgal, and the heart. Three: fire and water and wind (ruach). Fire above, and water below, and wind, a statute deciding between them. And a sign of the matter: the fire bears the water. Mem is silent, Shin hisses, Alef, a statute deciding between them.
תלי בעולם כמלך על כסאו. גלגל בשנה כמלך במדינה. לב בנפש כמלך במלחמה. גם את כל חפץ זה לעומת זה עשה האלהים. טוב לעומת רע. טוב מטוב ורע מרע. הטוב מבחין את הרע והרע מבחין את הטוב. טובה שמורה לטובים ורעה שמורה לרעים:
The Teli in the world is like a king upon his throne. The Galgal in the year is like a king in a province. The heart in the soul (nefesh) is like a king in war. "Also every desire, this one opposite that one, has ha-Elohim made." Good opposite evil: good from good and evil from evil. The good distinguishes the evil, and the evil distinguishes the good. Good is kept for the good ones, and evil is kept for the evil ones.
שלשה כל אחד לבדו עומד. ז' חלוקין שלשה מול שלשה וחק מכריע בינתים. שנים עשר עומדין במלחמה שלשה אוהבים שלשה שונאים שלשה מחיים שלשה ממיתים. שלשה אוהבים הלב והאזנים והפה. שלשה שונאים הכבד והמרה והלשון. ואל מלך נאמן מושל בכולן, אחד על גבי שלשה שלשה על גבי שבעה שבעה על גבי שנים עשר וכולן אדוקין זה בזה:
Three: each one stands by itself. Seven are divided: three against three, and a statute deciding between them. Twelve stand in war: three lovers, three haters, three life-givers, three killers. Three lovers: the heart and the ears and the mouth. Three haters: the liver and the gall and the tongue. And El, faithful King, rules over them all: one over three, three over seven, seven over twelve; and all of them are bound fast to one another.
וכיון שצפה אברהם אבינו ע"ה והביט וראה וחקר והבין וחקק וחצב וצרף וצר ועלתה בידו אז נגלה עליו אדון הכל ב"ה והושיבהו בחיקו ונשקו על ראשו וקראו אוהבי וכרת לו ברית ולזרעו והאמין בה' ויחשבה לו צדקה. וכרת לו ברית בין עשר אצבעות רגליו והיא ברית המילה, ועשר אצבעות ידיו והוא הלשון. וקשר לו עשרים ושתים אותיות בלשונו וגלה לו את יסודן. משכן במים דלקם באש רעשן ברוח בערן בשבעה נהגם בשנים עשר מזלות:
And when Abraham our father, peace be upon him, gazed, and looked, and saw, and probed, and understood, and engraved, and hewed, and combined, and formed, and it came up in his hand, then the Lord of All, blessed be He, was revealed to him, and sat him in His bosom, and kissed him upon his head, and called him "My beloved," and cut a covenant with him and with his seed; "and he believed in YHVH, and He reckoned it to him as righteousness." And He cut a covenant with him between the ten toes of his feet, and that is the covenant of circumcision, and the ten fingers of his hands, and that is the tongue. And He bound for him the twenty-two letters in his tongue, and revealed to him their foundation. He drew them in water, kindled them in fire, shook them in wind, burned them in seven, led them in twelve constellations.
| 1. Three fathers: whose?grammatical | Reading A Three fathers and their offspring: the three primary letters/elements under a deliberately paternal name, generating offspring. | Reading B Avot used loosely for 'principles', as at 3:2 and 5:3. |
| Editorial note The masculine avot is rendered as written. Its relation to the immot of chapters 2-3 is left open. | ||
| 2. Where does the sentence break?grammatical | Reading A Break after 'soul': the faithful witnesses are world, year, soul; then 'a statute of twelve, and seven, and three' (or 'the statute: twelve, seven and three') begins a new clause. | Reading B No break after 'soul': 'soul-statute' (the soul as a statute or law), so that the third witness is 'the statute of the soul' and the numbers twelve, seven and three stand on their own. |
| Editorial note The unpunctuated source can be divided in more than one way. The body breaks after 'soul' and takes 'statute' with the numbers. A third option reads 'the statute' as a heading: 'the statute: twelve, seven and three'. The doubt is recorded, not resolved. Note also the in-text variant 'ten' for 'twelve': with 'twelve' the numbers add up to the twenty-two letters; with 'ten' they would point to the ten sefirot. | ||
| 3. The Teli: a dragon, or an axis?semantic | Reading A the celestial dragon (the lunar nodes / Draco) | Reading B the axis on which the sphere is suspended (root t-l-y, 'to hang') |
| Editorial note Transliterated in the body. Construals are in the footnote. | ||
| 4. Wind, or breath?semantic | Reading A wind, the element mediating between fire and water | Reading B breath, echoing the ruach of the Living God as first sefirah (SY 1:9) |
| Editorial note Rendered 'wind (ruach)' in the body, with the Hebrew kept so that the breath sense remains visible. | ||
| 5. "My beloved", or "My friend"?intertextual | Reading A 'My beloved', the affective sense, consonant with the bosom and the kiss | Reading B 'My friend', the covenantal sense of Isa 41:8 (zera Avraham ohavi) |
| Editorial note 'Beloved' is chosen because the immediate context is the bosom and the kiss. The Isaiah 41:8 'friend' sense is noted in apparatus. | ||
| 6. The tongue between the fingersgrammatical | Reading A 'and that is the tongue', taken literally: the tongue itself is the term set between the ten fingers, the organ of the letters | Reading B 'and that is [the covenant of] the tongue', parallel to the covenant of circumcision just named |
| Editorial note The source's elliptical 'that is the tongue' is rendered literally. | ||
Suggested use: read the Hebrew aloud once, then take the places one at a time. The sheet does not choose between the readings; the edition's own leaning is in each editorial note.