How claim ratings work
Each fringe article that checks a specific claim carries a rating. A rating is the editor's judgment about one stated claim against the sources listed on that page. This page says what each word means and what it does not.
The five ratings
- documented
-
The claim, exactly as worded, is supported by the sources listed on that page.
It does not endorse the wider reading an article or a critic builds on top of the claim.
Given to: Read the Record: The Open Cultic Register of Michele Lamy and Rick Owens
- misattributed
-
Something real happened, but the claim credits it to the wrong person, source, date or cause.
It does not say the underlying event was invented.
- partly accurate
-
Some parts of the claim hold and others do not. The rating line on the page says which parts.
It is not a midpoint between true and false. Read the explanation, not the label.
Given to: Baal Is Not a Demon, Two Campaigns, Not One: The Balenciaga 2022 Receipts the Conspiracy Got Wrong
- unsupported
-
The sources we could find do not support the central assertion.
It is not proof that the thing did not happen. A source we could not find would change it.
Given to: Bohemian Grove: The Documented Record
- unresolved
-
The sources conflict, or are too thin to decide.
It is not a way of avoiding a verdict where the sources do decide.
Who chooses, and how
- The editor chooses the rating and writes the one-line explanation. No script infers it.
- A rating applies to the claim quoted at the top of the article, not to every statement in the article.
- The claim is quoted as it circulates, with who made it and when it first appeared where that is known.
- Every rating is dated. If a source changes the picture, the rating and its date change with it.
How sources are marked
- Each source is tagged primary, press, academic or witness.
- A source whose link no longer resolves stays listed, marked with the date it was last checked, so a reader can still find it by title.
- Some publishers block automated checks. A blocked link is not treated as dead, and it is not claimed to be verified either.
What a rating is not
- It is not a ruling on a person's character or beliefs. Where someone has spoken for themselves, the article reports that and stops there.
- It is not a prediction. It records what the sources show on the date given.
Machine-readable markup
Each rated article also carries schema.org ClaimReview data with the same claim, rating and explanation as the visible box.
Search engines have largely stopped showing fact-check labels, so this is for machines and archives that still read it,
not a promise of how any search engine will display the page.
Corrections
If a source we cite is wrong, or a source we missed changes a rating, write to the editor through the editor page. A rating changed after publication carries its new date.