Text · jewish mysticism

Heikhalot Rabbati 29-30: Israel's Request for Torah e Academies and the Crown, and the Angels' Objection

היכלות רבתי · פרקים כט-ל

Heikhalot Rabbati · The Greater Palaces · Anonymous (pseudepigraphically ascribed to R. Akiva and R. Ishmael)

canonicalHebrewlate antique / post-talmudic redaction; pseudepigraphically Tannaitictr. Hekhal Targum Project (machine-assisted, provisional)CC-BY-SA-4.0
  • TranslatorHekhal Targum Project (machine-assisted, provisional)
  • LicenceCC-BY-SA-4.0
  • Statuscanonical
  • Last revised2026-11-13
⁂ In depth a fuller, illustrated account

About Heikhalot Rabbati 29-30: Israel's Request for Torah, the Academies and the Crown, and the Angels' Objection

Heikhalot Rabbati 29-30 is a dialogue about the cost and the gift of Torah. Israel complain that building the house and studying Torah is too great a burden; God answers that he too did not do well, accepts their rebuke, and offers them whatever they ask. They ask for abundant Torah, for academies, for authority over kings, for shining faces and, "if you are worthy of this seal", for the use of the crown, so that no ignorant person will be among them. The ministering angels, who fought a great war with God over it, object: if the secret goes out, Torah will no longer come by toil, and the small will be made equal to the great and the fool to the wise. The edition keeps the numbers, the offices (the heads of the exiles, the fathers of the court, the fixing of months) and the opaque clauses of the angels' plea as the Hebrew gives them, and records in the apparatus the places where English cannot show whether "you" is Israel or God.

Heikhalot Rabbati 29-30: Israel's Request for Torah, the Academies and the Crown, and the Angels' Objection

Heikhalot Rabbati · The Greater Palaces

היכלות רבתי · פרקים כט-ל

canonical late antique / post-talmudic redaction; pseudepigraphically Tannaitic Hebrew Anonymous (pseudepigraphically ascribed to R. Akiva and R. Ishmael) tr. Hekhal Targum Project (machine-assisted draft; pending scholarly review)

This edition presents the verbatim Hebrew text of the passage beside a fresh English rendering and a critical apparatus. It is a provisional scholarly draft, released openly for correction and not yet reviewed by a credentialed editor.

The apparatus carries a running commentary, notes on the controlled vocabulary and the rendering chosen for each term, any doctrinally-live ambiguity preserved with both readings, and cross-references to the lexicon. The original-language text is reproduced verbatim from the digital source credited in the provenance line of this page; any modern English translation still under copyright is cited as a comparand only.

עמדו ישראל לשפוך תרעומת לפני אביהם שבשמים לומר צרות הרבה הפלת עלינו טורח גדול ומשאוי גדול אמרת לנו בנו לי בית אף על פי שאתם בונים עסקו בתורה זו תשובת עבדיו:

כי בטלה גדולה היתה לכם מן הגליות והייתי מתאוה מתי אשמע דברי תורה מפיכם כי אתם לא עשיתם יפה שלקחתם מכבודי וכעסתי עליכם ועמדתי ועשיתי על עירי ועל ביתי ועל בני כלה ואני לא עשיתי יפה שעמדתי לנגדכם וחתמתי עליכם גזר דין בודאי שהיה עומדת לעולם ולעולמי עולמים ותהא לי תחרות מדה שאין להם ארך או שתים או עשר או שלשים אם בגבורות עד מאה והלכה לה אלא שאתם הוכחתם אותי אתם יפה עשיתם קבלתי עלי תוכחתם:

כי ערבה עלי אנחות ישראל וכסתה אותו תאוה נתחננו באזני דבריכם ומתקבלים אמרי פיכם אתם עסקו בבית בחירתי ותורה מפיכם לא תמוש בעל נפלאות אני בעל פרישות אני בעל פלא ונסים אני נקרא בעל גבורות לפני מתרגשות נסים ותמהין לפני כסאי מי הקדימני ולא שלמתי מי קראני ולא עניתיו אמרו לפני משאלותי:

בתי גנזי ובתי אוצרותי ואין כל דבר חסר בהם אמרו משאלותיכם ותאות נפשיכם מיד תעשה כי אין עת כעת הזה ששהה נפשי עד שראיתי אתכם ואין זמן כזמן הזה שדבקה אהבתכם בלבי:

אני יודע מה אתם מבקשים ולבי הכיר מה אתם מתאוים תורה מרובה אתם מבקשים והמון למודים ורוב שמועות לשאול הלכה אתם מצפים ולהמקרב אתם מחמדין להרבות תורה להפלאות תושיה גבעות גבעות להפליא תלמוד בחוצות ופלפול ברחובות להרבות תורה כחול הים והלכות כעפרות תבל:

להושיב ישיבות בשערי לפרש מהם אסור והתר לטמא בהן את הטמא ולטהר בהן את הטהור להכשיר בהן את הכשר ולפסול בהן את הפסול להכיר בהן את החיים להורות לנדות מה יעשו לקשור קשרים בראשיכם ועטרות מלכות לכוף מלכים להשתחות לכם ולזקק רוזנים להשתטח לפניכם להפקיע שמכם בכל כיפה וזכרכם בכרכי הים להאיר פניכם כזריחת היום ובין עיניכם ככוכב הנוגה ואם תזכו לחותם זה להשתמש בכתר עם הארץ לא יהיה בכם וכסיל וטפש לא ימצא בכם:

אתם שמחים ומשרתי עצבים שרז זה אחד מן הרזים היוצאים מבית גנזי קול ישיבת שלכם כעגלי מרכבה לא בעמל לא ביגיעה אלא בשם חותם זה ובזכרון כתר נורא התאוה תאוה לכם והדאגה דאגה לכם רבים מתו מאנחותיכם ויוצא נשמתם על שמע קולכם:

עושר וממון מתגבר עליכם גדולי עולם ידבקו בכם משפחה שאתם נושאים ממנה וחסות מכל צדדיה המתברך בכם מבורך המשתבח בכם משובח מצדיקי רבים נקרין מזכי בריות קורין אתכם קביעות חדשים מכם יצא ועבור שנים מערמת חכמתכם:

על ידיכם נשיאים נשמעים על פיכם אבות בית דין עומדים ראשי גליות אתם מעמידין שופטי עיירות מרשות שלכם תקנות עולם מכם תצא ואין מי חולק עליה מלחמה רבה נלחמו עמי משרתי קטיגור גדול מלאכי השרת זה תשובה שלו:

רז זה אל יצא מבית גנזיך וסתר ערמה מאוצרותיך אל השם בשמרם פארי אל תראה תרמה בני אדם מדברותינו מגיע מדורותינו בתורה במדה שאין יגעין ובאין מן הדורות ואילך יקימוה בעמל ובתשנוק גדול זהו כבודך וזהו תפארתך כשהן משבחין וסודרין לפניך קורין בלבב שלם לך מתחננים בנפש חפצה יעמוד בידינו מה שקרינו ותקיים בידינו מה ששנינו יתפשו כל מה שישמעו אזנינו יחזק לבבינו נתיבות תלמוד ששמעו מפי הרב אבל אם רז זה יצא לפניך נשוו קטן כגדול וכסיל כחכם זה תשובת עבדיו:
Israel stood up to pour out a complaint before their Father who is in heaven, saying: Many troubles you have cast upon us, a great burden and a great load. You said to us: Build me a house; even though you are building, occupy yourselves with this Torah. This is the answer of his servants.

For there was a great idleness for you from the exiles, and I longed: when shall I hear words of Torah from your mouths? For you did not do well that you took from my glory, and I was angry with you, and I arose and made a full end upon my city, and upon my house, and upon my sons. And I did not do well that I stood against you and sealed upon you a decree of judgment that would surely have stood for ever and to the ages of ages; and there would have been for me a contest of measure, which have no length: either two, or ten, or thirty, if by mighty acts up to a hundred; and it has gone. But you rebuked me. You did well; I accepted upon myself your rebuke.

For the sighs of Israel were sweet to me, and desire covered it. Your words were made gracious in my ears, and the sayings of your mouth are accepted. Occupy yourselves in the house of my choice, and the Torah shall not depart from your mouth. I am a master of wonders; I am a master of separation; I am called a master of wonder and miracles, a master of mighty acts. Before me miracles are stirred, and wonders before my throne. Who has preceded me, and I did not repay? Who has called me, and I did not answer him? Say before me my requests.

The houses of my treasures and the houses of my storehouses, and nothing at all is lacking in them. Say your requests and the desire of your souls; at once it shall be done. For there is no time like this time, that my soul tarried until I saw you, and there is no season like this season, that your love clave to my heart.

I know what you ask, and my heart has recognised what you desire. Abundant Torah you ask, and a multitude of learnings, and many traditions; to ask halakhah you look; and to be brought near you desire; to multiply Torah, to make wondrous sound wisdom, hills upon hills; to make learning wondrous in the streets and sharp disputation in the squares; to multiply Torah like the sand of the sea and halakhot like the dust of the earth.

To seat academies in my gates, to explain from them what is forbidden and what is permitted; to declare unclean by them the unclean and to declare clean the clean; to declare fit by them the fit and to declare unfit the unfit; to recognise by them the living; to instruct menstruants what they should do; to tie knots on your heads, and crowns of kingship; to compel kings to bow down to you, and to refine rulers to prostrate themselves before you; to make your name go out in every vault and your memory in the cities of the sea; to make your faces shine like the rising of the day, and between your eyes like the star Nogah. And if you are worthy of this seal, to make use of the crown, no am ha-arets will be among you, and no fool or dullard will be found among you.

You are glad, and my servants are grieved. For this secret is one of the secrets that go out from the house of my treasures. The sound of your academy is like the carts of the chariot, not by labour, not by toil, but by the name of this seal and by the remembrance of a fearsome crown. The desire is desire for you, and the care is care for you. Many have died from your sighs, and their breath goes out at the sound of your voice.

Wealth and money grow strong upon you; the great of the world will cleave to you; a family from which you take, and shelter from all its sides. Whoever is blessed in you is blessed; whoever is praised in you is praised. You are called ‘justifiers of the many’; they call you ‘meritors of creatures’. The fixing of months goes out from you, and the intercalation of years from the cunning of your wisdom.

By your hands the nesi’im are heard; at your mouth the fathers of the court stand; the heads of the exiles you appoint; the judges of the towns are from your authority; eternal ordinances go out from you, and there is none who disputes it. A great war my servants fought with me, a great accuser, the ministering angels. This is his answer.

This secret, let it not go out from the house of your treasures, nor the hidden cunning from your storehouses. Not the Name, in their keeping, my adornments. Let there not be seen, deceit of human beings, from our speeches. It reaches from our generations in the Torah, in a measure in which there are no toilers, and those who come from the generations onward will establish it with toil and with great straining. This is your glory and this is your beauty, when they praise and set in order before you, reading with a whole heart, to you they supplicate with a willing soul: may what we have read stand in our hands, and what we have learned be established in our hands; may all that our ears hear be held fast; may the paths of study that they heard from the mouth of the teacher strengthen our heart. But if this secret goes out before you, the small will be made equal to the great and the fool to the wise. This is the answer of his servants.
Provisional draft (pending scholarly review)
An orientation

This edition sets the verbatim Hebrew beside a fresh English rendering and a critical apparatus: a running commentary on the passage, notes on the controlled vocabulary and the rendering chosen for each term, and cross-references to the lexicon and to related sections. It is a provisional scholarly draft, released openly for correction and not yet reviewed by a credentialed editor.

Controlled terms noted in this passage: kavod (rendered as glory), malach (rendered as angel), chotam (rendered as seal), merkavah (rendered as chariot), mayim (rendered as water). For each, the apparatus carries the sense set and the reason for the rendering chosen.

Apparatus
? Questions this edition answers

At a glance

What happens in Heikhalot Rabbati 29-30?
Israel complain that building the house and studying Torah is a great burden. God answers, accepts their rebuke, and offers them whatever they ask. They ask for abundant Torah, for academies, for authority over kings and, if they are worthy of "this seal", for the use of the crown. The ministering angels object that Torah acquired without toil would make the small equal to the great and the fool to the wise.
Does God really say he did wrong?
In 29 §2 the Hebrew has "I did not do well" and "I accepted upon myself your rebuke", and the edition renders it without softening. The nouns "my house" and "my sons" recall the tradition in b. Berakhot 3a where God laments the destruction; the edition records the verbal overlap and does not claim the author knew it.
What are "this seal" and "the crown"?
In 30 §1-2 the academies' work is done "not by labour, not by toil, but by the name of this seal and by the remembrance of a fearsome crown". It is the seal of the glossary used differently from the angelic seal at the gates of the palaces. The chapters do not name a Prince of the Torah; the link to those traditions is thematic only.
Which offices and institutions does it list?
30 §3-4 lists the fixing of months and the intercalation of years, the nesi'im, the fathers of the court, the heads of the exiles and the judges of the towns. The edition renders them as the Hebrew gives them and does not date the passage or identify the offices with any historical institution.
Why does "you" change meaning in the English?
English has one word for singular and plural. In 29 §1 Israel address God, and the verbs are singular ("you have cast", "you said"); the command they quote is God's plural address to them. From 29 §2 to 30 §4 God speaks to Israel and the Hebrew "you" is plural; in 30 §5 it is singular again (the angels speaking to God). The apparatus marks this.
Is this translation reliable?
It is a machine-assisted, provisional draft that has not been reviewed by a credentialed editor; every rendering decision, crux and open reading is recorded in the apparatus, and the Hebrew is reproduced from the Wertheimer recension as transmitted via Sefaria.
Tradition
jewish-mysticism
Language
Hebrew
Period
late antique / post-talmudic redaction; pseudepigraphically Tannaitic
Attribution
Anonymous (pseudepigraphically ascribed to R. Akiva and R. Ishmael)
Translator
Hekhal Targum Project (machine-assisted, provisional)
License
CC-BY-SA-4.0
Provenance
The Heikhalot Rabbati is a late-antique Hebrew work, in the public domain by age. The Hebrew is reproduced verbatim from the Wertheimer (Batei Midrashot) recension as transmitted in the digital transcription published on Sefaria and credited accordingly (Sefaria lists its licence as unknown; a verbatim transcription of a public-domain text carries no new copyright under US law); collation against the printed edition remains an outstanding editorial step. This English rendering and its apparatus are a provisional scholarly draft, released openly for correction and not yet reviewed by a credentialed editor. The Smith/Scholem/Karr English of this work remains under copyright and is cited as a comparand only.

Further reading

Cite this page

Stable URLs are part of the editorial commitment. This address will not change.

Anonymous (pseudepigraphically ascribed to R. Akiva and R. Ishmael). "Heikhalot Rabbati 29-30: Israel's Request for Torah, the Academies and the Crown, and the Angels' Objection." Hekhal: An Open Reference for Esoteric Tradition. Last modified November 13, 2026. https://hekhal.org/texts/heikhalot-rabbati-29-30-the-request-and-the-objection-targum.

Free · Reader's edition

Take this text with you.

This edition as a book: the original and the English facing each other, the full apparatus and notes, a citation line and the licence, typeset to print or to read on an e-reader. The text stays free online; the files are yours to keep and share.

  • PDF · 18 pp · 222 KB
  • ePub · 16 KB
  • Original + English
  • Full apparatus
  • Cite-ready

Cite The volume is deposited on Zenodo: doi:10.5281/zenodo.24073277

Included The whole of Heikhalot Rabbati in one volume: 23 parts, 269 pages.

The links arrive by email too. Reply "stop" to any message and you are off every list. How we use your address.