Text · jewish mysticism

3 Enoch 27-28; the keeper of the books d the Watchers and Holy Ones

ספר היכלות

Sefer Hekhalot · The Book of the Palaces · Anonymous (told in the name of R. Ishmael)

canonicalHebrewdate uncertain; a Hebrew work of the Hekhalot literature, printed in this shorter form by A. Jellinek in 1873tr. Hekhal Targum Project (machine-assisted draft; pending scholarly review)CC-BY-SA-4.0
  • TranslatorHekhal Targum Project (machine-assisted draft; pending scholarly review)
  • LicenceCC-BY-SA-4.0
  • Statuscanonical
  • Last revised2026-11-14
⁂ In depth a fuller, illustrated account

About 3 Enoch 27-28; the keeper of the books, and the Watchers and Holy Ones

3 Enoch (Sefer Hekhalot, "the Book of the Palaces") is a Hebrew work of the Hekhalot literature, told in the name of R. Ishmael, in which the angel Metatron says that he was once Enoch son of Jared. Above the seraphim a prince keeps the treasury of the books and brings them to the Holy One to be read in the great court in Aravot. Above all these are four great princes called Watchers and Holy Ones, two Watchers and two Holy Ones. The Holy One does nothing in His world without first taking counsel with them, and they stand before Him when He sits in judgment with the books of the living and the books of the dead open.

3 Enoch 27-28: the keeper of the books, and the Watchers and Holy Ones

Sefer Hekhalot · The Book of the Palaces

ספר היכלות

canonical date uncertain; a Hebrew work of the Hekhalot literature, printed in this shorter form by A. Jellinek in 1873 Hebrew Anonymous (told in the name of R. Ishmael) tr. Hekhal Targum Project (machine-assisted draft; pending scholarly review)

This edition presents the Hebrew text of the passage beside a fresh English rendering and a critical apparatus. It is a provisional scholarly draft, released openly for correction and not yet reviewed by a credentialed editor.

The apparatus carries a running commentary, notes on the controlled vocabulary and the rendering chosen for each term, any doctrinally live ambiguity preserved with both readings, and cross-references to the lexicon. The Hebrew is the digitized text credited in the provenance line of this page, corrected to the printed page at the places listed there; the printed editor’s notes are removed from it and reported in the notes. Any modern English translation still under copyright is cited as a comparand only.

אר״י א״ל מטטרון מלאך שר הפנים, למעלה מן השרפים יש שר אחד מעולה מכל השרים מופלא מכל המשרתים דבריאל ה׳ שמו שהוא ממונה על גנזי ספריו והוא מוציא ומביא דלוסקות והוא פותח ונוטל את הספרים ונותן אותם לידי הקב״ה, והקב״ה נוטלם מידו ונותן אותם לפניו לידי הסופרים לקרות בב״ד הגדול שברום ערבות רקיע בפני פמליא של מעלה. ולמה נקרא שמו דבריאל מפני שכל דבור ודבור יוצא ממנו מלאך ועומד בשירות של מלאכי השרת ואומרים שירה לפניו בשעת הגיע זמן לומר קדוש.

אמר רבי ישמעאל א״ל מטטרון מלאך שה”פ, למעלה מכל אלו יש ארבעה שרים הגדולים עירין וקדישין שמם, רמים ונכבדים נוראים ונחמדים נפלאים ואדירים, גדולים מכל בני עליונים ואין כמותן בכל שרי העליונים ואין כערכן בכל המשרתים כולם, שכל אחד ואחד שקול כנגד כולם, ומחיצתן כנגד כסא הכבוד וזיו דמותן מעין זיו השכינה והן מפארין מפאר השכינה ומשבחין בשבח השכינה, ולא עוד אלא שהקב״ה אין עושה דבר בעולמו עד שנמלך עמהם תחלה ואח״כ עושה דבר בעולמו שנאמר בגזרת עירין פתגמא ומאמר קדישין שאלתא, עירין שנים קדישין שנים, וכיצד הן אומרים לפני הקב״ה מלמד שעיר אחד עומד לפני הקב״ה מזה וקדיש אחד עומד מזה,

ולעולם הן מגביהין שפלים עד מרום והן משפילין גאים עדי ארץ, ובכל יום ויום כשהקב״ה יושב על כסא דין ודן את כל העולם כולו, וספרי חיים וספרי מתים פתוחין לפניו כל בני עליונים עומדין לפניו ביראה בפחד ורעדה, באותה שעה הקב״ה יושב כדיין על כסא הפנים, לבושו לבן כמו שלג ושער ראשו כמו צמר נקי ומעילו כולו כאור נוגה וכולו מלא צדקה כשריון, והן עירין וקדישין עומדין לפניו כשוטרין לפני השופטים, והם נושאים ונותנים בכל דבר ודבר וגומרים את הדבר שבא לפני הקב״ה בדין כענין שנאמר בגזרת עירין פתגמא ומאמר קדישין שאלתא, מהם פוסקין הדברים ומהם גוזרין בב״ד הגדול שבערבות, מהם שואלין את השאלות מלפני הגבורה ומהם גומרים את הדברים כנגד למעלה, מהם מקימים את הגזרות בארץ מתחת כענין שנאמר ואלו עיר וקדיש מן שמיא נחת קרא בחיל, וכן אמר גודו אילנא וקציצו ענפוהי אתרו אפיה ובדרו אגביה.

ולמה נקרא שמם עירין וקדישין שהן מקדשין את הגוף והנשמה בפולסאות שלהן ביום השלישי של דין שנאמר יחיינו מיומים ביום השלישי יקימנו ונחיה לפניו.
R. Ishmael said: Metatron, the angel, the Prince of the Presence, said to me: Above the seraphim there is one prince, more excellent than all the princes, more wondrous than all the ministers: Dabriel YHWH is his name, who is appointed over the treasuries of His books. And he brings out and brings in the cases, and he opens and takes the books and gives them into the hands of the Holy One, blessed be He; and the Holy One, blessed be He, takes them from his hand and gives them, before Him, into the hands of the scribes, to read in the great court that is in the height of Aravot, the firmament, in the presence of the household on high. And why is his name called Dabriel? Because from each and every utterance that goes forth from him there is an angel, and it stands in the hymns of the ministering angels, and they say a song before Him at the hour when the time arrives to say “Holy”.

R. Ishmael said: Metatron, the angel, the Prince of the Presence, said to me: Above all these there are four great princes, Watchers and Holy Ones is their name: high and honored, fearsome and desirable, wondrous and noble, greater than all the children of the upper ones; and there is none like them among all the princes of the upper ones, and none of their worth among all the ministers, all of them, for each and every one is weighed against them all. And their enclosure is over against the throne of glory, and the radiance of their likeness is of the kind of the radiance of the Shekhinah, and they are made beautiful from the beauty of the Shekhinah and are praised with the praise of the Shekhinah. And not only that, but the Holy One, blessed be He, does not do a thing in His world until He has taken counsel with them first, and afterwards He does the thing in His world, as it is said: “By the decree of the Watchers is the matter, and by the word of the Holy Ones the question.” Watchers, two; Holy Ones, two. And how do they speak before the Holy One, blessed be He? This teaches that one Watcher stands before the Holy One, blessed be He, on this side, and one Holy One stands on that side,

and forever they raise the lowly up on high and they bring the proud down to the earth. And each and every day, when the Holy One, blessed be He, sits on the throne of judgment and judges the whole world entire, and the books of the living and the books of the dead are open before Him, all the children of the upper ones stand before Him in fear, in dread and trembling. At that hour the Holy One, blessed be He, sits as a judge on the throne of the Presence: His garment white like snow, and the hair of His head like clean wool, and His robe all of it like the light of brightness, and all of Him full of righteousness as a coat of mail. And they, the Watchers and Holy Ones, stand before Him like officers before the judges, and they debate each and every matter and conclude the matter that has come before the Holy One, blessed be He, in judgment, as it is said: “By the decree of the Watchers is the matter, and by the word of the Holy Ones the question.” Some of them decide the matters, and some of them decree in the great court that is in Aravot; some of them ask the questions from before the Power, and some of them conclude the matters toward what is above; some of them establish the decrees on the earth below, as it is said: “And behold, a Watcher and a Holy One came down from heaven. He cried aloud, and thus he said: Hew down the tree and cut off its branches, strip off its foliage and scatter its fruit.”

And why is their name called Watchers and Holy Ones? Because they sanctify the body and the soul with their lashes on the third day of judgment, as it is said: “He will revive us after two days; on the third day He will raise us up, and we shall live before Him.”
Provisional draft (pending scholarly review)
An orientation

This edition sets the verbatim Hebrew beside a fresh English rendering and a critical apparatus: a running commentary on the passage, notes on the controlled vocabulary and the rendering chosen for each term, and cross-references to the lexicon and to related sections. It is a provisional scholarly draft, released openly for correction and not yet reviewed by a credentialed editor.

Controlled terms noted in this passage: metatron (rendered as metatron), sar-ha-panim (rendered as prince-of-the-presence), seraphim (rendered as seraphim), malach (rendered as angel), kisei-ha-kavod (rendered as throne-of-glory), kavod (rendered as glory). For each, the apparatus carries the sense set and the reason for the rendering chosen.

Apparatus
? Questions this edition answers

At a glance

What is in 3 Enoch 27-28?
Above the seraphim a prince keeps the treasury of the books and brings them to the Holy One to be read in the great court in Aravot. Above all these are four great princes called Watchers and Holy Ones, two Watchers and two Holy Ones. The Holy One does nothing in His world without first taking counsel with them, and they stand before Him when He sits in judgment with the books of the living and the books of the dead open.
Has this been translated into English before?
Yes. Hugo Odeberg published a complete English translation beside his Hebrew text in 1928, and P. Alexander's translation appeared in The Old Testament Pseudepigrapha in 1983. Sefaria has the Hebrew of this section and no English (checked 2026-11-10). This edition is an openly licensed English set beside the Hebrew, with every rendering decision recorded; it does not claim to be the first.
Which Hebrew text is this, and where do chapters 16 to 22 come from?
The Hebrew is the shorter printed text of A. Jellinek (Bet ha-Midrasch V, 1873) as J.D. Eisenstein reprinted it in Otzar Midrashim, taken from Sefaria (public domain) and compared word by word with a scan of the printed book; fifteen readings were corrected to the print before translation. The chapter numbers are those of Hugo Odeberg's edition of 1928, which has 48 chapters. By his description the shorter print lacks chapters 16 to 22. This edition supplies them, with two additional fragments that he numbers 22B and 22C, from the Hebrew of Odeberg's own edition, in parts that say so.
Is this translation reliable?
It is a machine-assisted, provisional draft that has not been reviewed by a credentialed editor. Every rendering decision, crux and open reading is recorded in the apparatus beside the Hebrew, and corrections are welcome.
Tradition
jewish-mysticism
Language
Hebrew
Period
date uncertain; a Hebrew work of the Hekhalot literature, printed in this shorter form by A. Jellinek in 1873
Attribution
Anonymous (told in the name of R. Ishmael)
Translator
Hekhal Targum Project (machine-assisted draft; pending scholarly review)
License
CC-BY-SA-4.0
Provenance
Hebrew of 3 Enoch (Sefer Hekhalot, the Book of the Palaces) in its shorter printed form. The text is the one A. Jellinek printed in Bet ha-Midrasch V (Vienna, 1873), pages 170 to 190, as J.D. Eisenstein reprinted it in Otzar Midrashim, in the entry Metatron, under the heading 'Enoch is Metatron' (Sefaria files the section as 'The Angel Metatron (Chanoch)'). It was taken from Sefaria's digitization of Eisenstein (version 'Otzar Midrashim, New York, 1915', public domain; source record at the National Library of Israel, NNL_ALEPH001175329), fetched 2026-11-10. Hugo Odeberg, whose edition of 1928 divides the work into 48 chapters, describes Jellinek's print as holding chapters 1 to 15 and 23 to 48A; chapters 16 to 22 are not in it. This edition gives them, with two additional fragments that he numbers 22B and 22C, from the Hebrew of Odeberg's own edition, in parts that say so. The parts numbered 48B, 48C and 48D are the piece Eisenstein prints separately as 'Sefer Chanoch' from Bet ha-Midrasch II, page 114; Odeberg gives the same material, from the Alphabet of R. Akiva, as the end of his chapter 48. The chapter numbers are Odeberg's and are not in the printed Hebrew; the division into paragraphs is Hekhal's. On 2026-11-10 the digitization was compared word by word with a scan of the 1928 printing of Otzar Midrashim (archive.org, item otsarmidrashimbe121unse); for chapters 1 to 48A the 1915 printing that Sefaria names was not compared, because no scan of its second volume was found. For 48B to 48D the text layer of a scan of the 1915 printing (archive.org, item ozarmidrashimlib11unse, volume 1) was compared as well, and it shows the same three corrections. All 302 differences were read. Fifteen readings, at 17 places, where the digitization's wording differed from the printed page were corrected to the print before translation: in chapters 6, 10, 11, 23, 25, 26, 28, 29, 34, 37, 45 and 47 and in 48B and 48C. Those that change the sense are in chapters 11, 25, 29, 34, 37, 45 and 47 and in 48C. At 15 places the print abbreviates where the digitization writes the words out; these were left as digitized. The remaining differences were reading errors of the scan's text layer, page headings, and Eisenstein's own notes. Punctuation was not compared. Eisenstein's notes and his scripture references are removed from the Hebrew and reported in the notes of the part they belong to; words he prints in square brackets are kept, in the Hebrew and in the English. Not checked: Jellinek's own volumes, any manuscript, and, for the chapters of this shorter print, the Hebrew of Odeberg's edition, which has all 48 chapters.

Prior English translations

Hekhal does not claim to be the first English translation of a work where one already exists. Where prior translations are known they are listed here with their rights status, so a reader can see exactly what this edition adds and what it does not.

  • Odeberg, Hugo, 1928: 3 Enoch; or, The Hebrew Book of Enoch (Cambridge: University Press)public domainA Hebrew text in 48 chapters with a complete English translation, introduction and notes. Published in 1928, so in the public domain in the United States; its status elsewhere has not been checked.
  • Alexander, P., 1983: 3 (Hebrew Apocalypse of) Enoch, in J.H. Charlesworth (ed.), The Old Testament Pseudepigrapha, volume 1 (Doubleday)in copyrightA complete English translation with introduction and notes. In copyright.

Further reading

Cite this page

Stable URLs are part of the editorial commitment. This address will not change.

Anonymous (told in the name of R. Ishmael). "3 Enoch 27-28; the keeper of the books, and the Watchers and Holy Ones." Hekhal: An Open Reference for Esoteric Tradition. Last modified November 14, 2026. https://hekhal.org/texts/3-enoch-27-28-targum.

Free · Reader's edition

Take this text with you.

This edition as a book: the original and the English facing each other, the full apparatus and notes, a citation line and the licence, typeset to print or to read on an e-reader. The text stays free online; the files are yours to keep and share.

  • PDF · 20 pp · 230 KB
  • ePub · 14 KB
  • Original + English
  • Full apparatus
  • Cite-ready

Included The whole of 3 Enoch (Sefer Hekhalot) in one volume: 27 parts, 428 pages.

The links arrive by email too. Reply "stop" to any message and you are off every list. How we use your address.